Derek Thompson / Tooth Fairy

Tracy

Carly

Lily

Mick Donnelly

Ziggy

Tess

Randy

Gabe

Shelter Cove Kid

Kelly

Ben

Kyle

Duke

Tooth Fairy #1

Permit Woman

Coach

Announcer

Color Commentator

Brad

Josh

Andreas

Shelter Cove Mom

Amnesia Woman

Amnesia Daughter

Fan

Poltergeist Woman

Poltergeist Man

Crazed Fan

Teddy's Dad

Scared Woman

Talent Show Teacher

Himself

Amnesia Grandma

Gabe's Dad

Inmate

Sports Reporter

Shelter Cove Dad

Jerry (uncredited)