Amsterdam Vallon
Bill "The Butcher" Cutting
Jenny Everdeane
Boss Tweed
Happy Jack
Johnny Sirocco
"Priest" Vallon
Walter "Monk" McGinn
McGloin
Shang
Killoran
Reverend Raleigh
Mr. Schermerhorn
Jimmy Spoils
Hell-Cat Maggie
P.T. Barnum
One-Armed Priest
Young Amsterdam
Young Johnny
O'Connell Guard Leader
Plug Uglies Leader
Shirt Tails Leader
Chichesters Leader
Forty Thieves Leader
Calvinist Minister
Bill The Butcher's Gang #1
Bill The Butcher's Gang #2
Bill The Butcher's Gang #3
True Blue American Speaker
Jenny's Girl
Resident Woman
Black Joke Chief
Resident Man
Dead Rabbit Gang Member
Chinese at Sparrow's Pagoda
Elderly Chinese at Pagoda
Satan's Circus Singer
Rat Pit Game Master
Card Player (Harvey)
Undertaker
Medical Student
Army Recruiter
Passenger on Omnibus
Mrs. Schermerhorn
Horace Greeley
Miss Schermerhorn
Street Singer
Assistant Hangman
Condemned Man (Arthur)
Condemned Man (Seamus)
Legless Soldier
She-He
Recruiter
Harry Watkins / Lincoln
Uncle Tom
Mr. Shelby
Mr. Legree
Topsy
Miss Eliza
Assassin
Tap Dancer
Chinese Whore
Whore #1
Whore #2
Chinese Acrobat
Chinese General
Chinese Dancer
Chinese Boy Singer
Knife Act Caller
Surgeon
Archbishop
Provost Marshal Registrar
Unruly Man
Don Whiskerandos
Nativist Candidate
One-Armed Veteran
Drunken Repeater
The Mayor
Draft Official
Kerryonians Leader
American Guard Leader
Atlantic Guard Leader
Slaughter Housers Leader
Bowery Boys Leader
Bloodied Bureaucrat
Telegraph Operator #1 (voice)
Telegraph Operator #2 (voice)
Telegraph Operator #3 (voice)
Police Chief
Telegraph Operator
Robber on Dock
Woman Accomplice
General Wool
Gunboat Captain
Soldier in Mist
Wealthy Homeowner (uncredited)
Man in Tweed's Office (uncredited)
Bar Bouncer (uncredited)
Native (uncredited)
Citizen (uncredited)
Fireman (uncredited)
Tammany Man (uncredited)
Middle Class Man (uncredited)
Coach (uncredited)
Tweed's Whore (uncredited)
Priest's Gang Member (uncredited)
Rapist (uncredited)
Dead Rabbit Gang Member (uncredited)
Internee (uncredited)
Bill the Butcher's Gang Member (uncredited)
Italian Emigrant (uncredited)