Sarah Fier / Deena

Henry / Josh

Hannah Miller / Samantha Fraser

Solomon Goode / Nick Goode

Martin

'Real' Sarah Fier

George Fier

Lizzie / Kate

Elijah Goode / Mayor Will Goode

Isaac / Simon

'The Pastor' Cyrus Miller

Constance / Ziggy Berman

Abigail / Cindy Berman

Grace Miller / Mrs. Fraser

Mad Thomas / Tommy Slater

The Widow / Mrs. Lane

Caleb / Peter

Union Townsman 1

Union Townsman 2

Union Townswoman

Beth Kimball / Rachel Thompson

Jakob Berman

The Watchman / Officer Kapinski

Alice

Skull Mask

'Shame Killer' Isaac Milton

Billy Barker

'The Milkman' Harry Rooker

Ruby Lane

Young Nick Goode

Nightwing Killer

Adult Ziggy / C. Berman

Officer Kuzio

TV Anchor

Highschool Kid

Queen of Air and Darkness Girl