Bobby
Aaron
Henry
Wanda
Angela
Cherry
Robert
Tamara
Tina
Edgar
Jason
Anne
Debra Messing
Peter
Paul
Marty
Josh
Lucas
Tom
Louis
Lawrence Grape
Hannah
Brian
Bruce
Joel
Steve
James Baldwin
Eleanor Roosevelt
Samantha
Grape's Neighbor
Melvin Funk
Polyamorous Man
Straight Older Woman
Rowdy Bear
Aaron's Assistant
Receptionist
Party Guest
Teenage Girl
Grindr Guy
Judgey Boy
Pride Awards Football Player
Football Player
Singing Waiter
Kristin Chenoweth
Paul's Grandma
Paul's Grandpa
Baseball Player
Baseball Player's Man
Harness Guy
Hot Santa
Vogueing Man
Movie Exec
Drag Queen
Paula
Handsome Grindr Guy
Wealthy Benefactor
Ben Stiller (uncredited)
Harvey Milk (uncredited)
Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)
Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)