Gene Carruthers
Noah Reed
Eugene Wexler
Sammy Devers
Ben Driskel
Abby Reed
Miss Halverson
Lilly Reed
Ronnie Harlow
Umpire
Witch
Kevin Lampkey
Chief Hartley
Hannah Driskel
Deb Harlow
Little Boy / Carruthers' Son
Ellie Evans
Edgar Palmer
The Witch (voice)
Emily
Baseball Fan (uncredited)
Town Kid (uncredited)
Diner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited)
Police Officer (uncredited)
Mom with Kids (uncredited)
Jogger (uncredited)
Dad in Theater (uncredited)
Book Signing Kid (uncredited)